Swiss prosecutor returns ‘Mesopotamian’ terracotta animal made by dealer’s 11 year old daughter—along with 5,000 seized antiquities
Ali Aboutaam, left, and brother Hicham Aboutaam of the Phoenix Ancient Art Company pose with a monumental marble head of the Emperor Tiberius, which is not believed to be among the seized items
© Alastair Miller/Bloomberg via Getty Images
A court in Geneva has released around 5,000 antiquities belonging to Ali Aboutaam of Phoenix Ancient Art which were seized in October 2017 on suspicion of having illicit provenances. A further 6,000 ancient items belonging to the New York- and Geneva-based dealer Aboutaam remain in the hands of the Swiss authorities, who believe them to be suspect.
However, according to a report in the Swiss publication Le Temps, one item had already been released—a terracotta animal which was labelled by Swiss police as Mesopotamian when it was seized last year. It was relinquished a few weeks later, when found to have been in fact made by Aboutaams 11-year-old daughter. The label attached reading "With love, for Daddy" may have been a give-away.
Neither the prosecutor, Claudio Mascotto, nor the Public Prosecutor's Office of Geneva would provide any comment on the case.
Aboutaams lawyer Didier Bottge, says: “These items should never have been frozen by the Swiss justice system, which is why we are very happy that they have been released. There is no proof of illicit provenance.” He adds: “They are still withholding around 6,000 items which are currently under expert consideration. I am confident that in a couple of months, more items will be released.” The 11,000 items withheld accounted for “a large part of the Geneva gallerys stock” making business “very difficult”, Bottges says. Their total value, he says, is hard to calculate “as some items have been in the familys possession for many years” but he estimates their total worth to amount to “dozens of millions”.
This is only a stage victory for Aboutaam, whose business Phoenix Ancient Art has been scrutinised by US, Egyptian and European authorities in the past. In January, the recently formed New York District Attorneys Antiquities Trafficking Unit, led by the Assistant District Attorney Matthew Bogdanos, seized six ancient Hellenic artefacts from Phoenix Ancient Art. The search warrant named the artefacts as potential evidence related to charges of stolen property, but Phoenix Ancient Art said in a statement: “Those pieces were consigned to us from an American collection that acquired them in the mid 1990s in London. Before that, we were happy to learn that these pieces were on loan to the Musée d'art et d'histoire in Geneva from October 1978-October 1981, and then for over a decade at the Getty Museum. This was information we had. What more can a dealer do?”
Among the 6,000 items still held by Swiss authorities are 18 Greek, Roman and Egyptian antiquities, valued at around $8m, which had been sent by a Colorado couple, Lynda and William Beierwaltes, to be sold by Aboutaam. They were among the items seized by Swiss authorities from a Geneva warehouse in February 2017. On 8 August (the same day that the Geneva court partially released Aboutaams items), the Beierwaltes filed a lawsuit in a Colorado court suing the Swiss government. According to the lawsuit, “neither the Office of Culture of the Swiss Confederation nor the Federal Customs Administration have asserted any proper legal basis for the seizure of the Beierwaltes property pursuant to international or Swiss law.”The Beierwaltes are seeking $24m in damages.
The Beierwaltes lawyer, Jessica Black Livingston of Hogan Lovells in Denver, tells The Art Newspaper:“The Swiss government took this action prior to any decision by the US court in connection with the Beierwaltes complaint, so we do not know whether filing the complaint impacted the Swiss governments decision.” She confirms that “the 18 items have not been returned to the Beierwaltes, nor have they been released to Phoenix to sell. The Beierwaltes suit is still pending, and they have not received the requested damages.”